As an SEO professional or business owner, choosing the right tools can be a game-changer for your business. In this article, we will compare Lumar and Screaming Frog, two of the most popular SEO tools.
To provide you with the most comprehensive analysis, we have used both tools for a month and conducted interviews with business owners and marketers who have had experience with them.
Through this research, we have gathered valuable insights into the features, pricing, customer support, and overall effectiveness of both tools. By the end of this article, you will clearly understand which tool is better suited for your specific SEO needs.
Table Of Contents
Quick Summary
Lumar is an SEO tool with advanced crawling capabilities, comprehensive reporting, integration with other tools, customizable dashboards, and excellent customer support.- Screaming Frog is an SEO tool with a user-friendly interface that provides comprehensive crawling, customizable filters, and data visualization.
- Lumar is better suited for larger and more complex websites while Screaming Frog is better suited for smaller websites and individuals on a tight budget.
What Is Lumar?
Lumar is a cloud-based SEO tool that analyzes and monitors websites for technical issues that could affect search engine rankings.
It provides a comprehensive site audit of a website’s structure, content, and backlinks, allowing users to identify and fix issues that could negatively impact their website’s performance.
What Is Screaming Frog?
Screaming Frog is a desktop website crawler for SEO analysis and optimization. It crawls websites to collect data on on-page SEO elements such as page titles, meta descriptions, headings, and links.
The tool offers a range of features to help users identify and fix website issues, including broken links, duplicate content, and missing metadata.
An SEO spider is a technical auditing tool used by SEO professionals to understand the website, collect information and find critical issues.
– Yasmin Aladdin, SEO consultant at Productive Shop
Features Comparison
Lumar
Lumar provides a comprehensive analysis of a website’s technical health. It helps website owners identify broken links, duplicate content, missing metadata, slow page load times, and problems that disable them from appearing on search engines.
The tool’s advanced crawling websites capabilities allow it to identify issues other tools may miss, such as issues with JavaScript rendering and AJAX.
It provides detailed reports and recommendations to help users fix these issues and improve their website’s overall SEO performance.
Also, Lumar offers integration with other tools, such as Google Analytics and Google Search Console, to provide a complete picture of website performance.
Screaming Frog
Screaming Frog helps website owners research keywords and identify on-page optimization issues on the entire site, such as missing or duplicate content and broken links.
The tool’s Screaming Frog SEO Spider crawls the website to identify what is wrong and provides a detailed report and recommendations to help users fix them.
Screaming Frog also includes more features, such as page speed analysis and XML sitemap generation, to improve website performance further.
The tool is handy for identifying technical issues that can negatively impact website visibility in search engine results pages.
Pricing Comparison
Lumar
Lumar’s pricing is based on the user’s specific needs and offers a quote-based pricing model. This means that the cost will depend on factors such as the size and complexity of the website, the number of crawls needed, and the more features required.
Interested users can contact Lumar for a quote, which includes access to all the tool’s features, such as unlimited crawls, custom user roles, and API access.
Screaming Frog
Screaming Frog offers two pricing plans: a free version and a paid version. A free version is a limited tool that crawls up to 500 URLs, while the paid version costs $183.10 per year and offers additional features.
These features include unlimited crawls, custom search, Google Analytics integration, XML sitemap creation, and more. Screaming Frog licenses are also provided at a discounted rate for bulk purchases of 5 or more licenses.
For 1 to 4 licenses, the cost is £199 per license per year.
Customer Support Comparison
Lumar
Lumar provides a dedicated account manager for each customer and email and phone support during business hours.
They also offer extensive documentation and training resources, including webinars and online courses, to help users get the most out of the tool.
Also, Lumar has an active community forum where users can ask questions and share insights with other users.
Screaming Frog
Screaming Frog also provides email support, a detailed user guide, and an FAQ section on their website. However, they do not offer dedicated account managers or phone support.
Screaming Frog’s support team is generally responsive to user inquiries, but response times may vary depending on the complexity of the issue and the number of support requests.
Lumar has a more comprehensive offering in customer support, with dedicated account managers, phone support, and extensive training resources.
Lumar Vs. Screaming Frog: Pros And Cons
Here are the pros and cons of using Lumar and Screaming Frog.
- Advanced Crawling Capabilities – Lumar can easily handle large and complex websites and provides advanced crawling capabilities to identify technical issues, broken links, and duplicate content.
- Comprehensive Reporting – Lumar provides detailed and comprehensive reports on website performance and SEO aspects, including crawl errors, site structure, page titles, meta descriptions, and more.
- Integration With Other Tools – Lumar integrates with other popular SEO tools, such as Google Analytics and Search Console, to provide a complete view of website performance.
- Customizable Dashboards – Users can create custom dashboards to track specific metrics and KPIs.
- Excellent Customer Support And Resources – Lumar offers an extensive knowledge base, webinars, and dedicated account managers for enterprise-level clients.
Higher Cost – Lumar is more expensive than other SEO tools, which may make it less accessible to smaller businesses or individuals on a tight budget.- Steep Learning Curve – Due to its advanced capabilities, Lumar can be more challenging to learn and use effectively than other SEO tools.
- Limited Keyword Research Capabilities – Lumar’s keyword research capabilities are limited compared to other dedicated keyword research tools.
- Affordable Pricing – Screaming Frog is relatively inexpensive compared to other SEO tools, making it accessible to smaller businesses and individuals on a tight budget.
- User-Friendly Interface – Screaming Frog has a user-friendly interface that is easy to learn and navigate.
- Comprehensive Crawling – Screaming Frog provides comprehensive crawling capabilities and can identify technical issues, duplicate content, and broken links.
- Customizable Filters – Users can create custom filters to focus on specific website performance and SEO aspects.
- Data Visualization – Screaming Frog provides easy-to-read graphs and charts that help users quickly identify trends and areas of concern.
- Limited Crawl Capacity – Screaming Frog has a limited crawl capacity compared to Lumar’s, which may make it less suitable for larger and more complex websites.
- No Integration With Other Tools – Screaming Frog does not integrate with other popular SEO tools, making it more challenging to get a complete view of website performance.
- No Keyword Research Capabilities – Screaming Frog does not have dedicated keyword research capabilities, which may require users to rely on other tools for this aspect of SEO.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is Lumar’s Used For?
Lumar’s is used for auditing and monitoring websites for technical SEO issues such as broken links, duplicate content, and crawl errors.
What Is The New Name Of Deepcrawl?
The new name for Deepcrawl is Lumar. The name was changed in 2022.
What Does Screaming Frog Do?
Screaming Frog allows crawling website URLs and collects data on on-page SEO elements such as title tags, meta descriptions, headers, etc.
Can Lumar’s And Screaming Frog Be Used Together?
Yes, Lumar’s and Screaming Frog can be used together. SEO professionals use both SEO tools to analyze a website’s technical SEO issues comprehensively.
How To Install Screaming Frog?
To install Screaming Frog, visit the official website and download the software for your operating system. Once downloaded, follow the installation wizard to complete the installation process.
Screaming Frog is compatible with Windows, macOS, and Ubuntu operating systems.
Lumar Vs. Screaming Frog: Which Should You Choose?
Lumar and Screaming Frog are powerful SEO tools with unique features and benefits. Lumar’s offers a comprehensive website analysis that is ideal for large websites while Screaming Frog is a cost-effective option that provides in-depth on-page analysis.
Ultimately, choosing these two tools depends on your business needs and budget. We recommend Lumar for its advanced reporting and analytics capabilities, which provide valuable insights for optimizing website performance.
Both Lumar and Screaming Frog are solid tools, offering valuable features for SEO analysis. However, when comparing them to SEMrush, it becomes apparent that SEMrush outperforms in terms of its beginner-friendly audit tool, and unmatched data accuracy.
Our #1 Recommendation: Ahrefs
Support
Price
Features
Security
